
c8c.ai / AI Training
Agentic Evaluation
An agent can produce a convincing final message and still fail the task. Assess the sequence of decisions, not just the last answer.
01 / The work
What the project can cover.
Task completion
Establish what counts as a completed task, then review the outcome against required steps, constraints, and evidence.
Tool-use review
Examine supplied tool-call traces for inappropriate actions, missing checks, unnecessary steps, and recovery after errors.
Escalation & recovery
Assess whether an agent stops, asks for clarification, or escalates when information is missing or an action exceeds its authority.
02 / People & collection
The right context for every judgment.
People
Recruit reviewers with experience of the workflow being evaluated. Customer service, operations, and specialist tasks require different definitions of success.
Collection
Use agreed scenarios and client-provided agent runs or controlled test environments. Capture the point of failure and its consequence as well as the final outcome.
Quality & sensitive-data handling
Review criteria, exception handling, permitted access, sensitive-data treatment, retention, and transfer requirements are agreed per project. A pilot establishes how instructions and review decisions will be applied.
03 / Metadata
Keep the evidence attached.
- Scenario identifier and success criteria
- Run identifier and ordered action references
- Completion, tool-use, and escalation labels
- Failure step, reviewer rationale, and disposition
04 / Delivery
A handoff your team can interpret.
- Run-level verdicts and criterion scores
- Step-level annotations on supplied traces
- Failure examples organized by workflow
- Recommendations for the next evaluation batch
Live system access, permitted actions, and test environments are agreed in advance. Testing does not imply deployment or operation of your agent.
05 / Questions
Before you scope a project.
Who works on a Agentic Evaluation project?
Recruit reviewers with experience of the workflow being evaluated. Customer service, operations, and specialist tasks require different definitions of success.
How does the work run?
Use agreed scenarios and client-provided agent runs or controlled test environments. Capture the point of failure and its consequence as well as the final outcome.
What is delivered?
Run-level verdicts and criterion scores; Step-level annotations on supplied traces; Failure examples organized by workflow; Recommendations for the next evaluation batch.
How are quality and sensitive data handled?
Review criteria, exception handling, permitted access, sensitive-data treatment, retention, and transfer requirements are agreed per project. A pilot establishes how instructions and review decisions will be applied.
What is outside the scope?
Live system access, permitted actions, and test environments are agreed in advance. Testing does not imply deployment or operation of your agent.
From brief to human signal